All posts by John Hughes

Contemplating the Mind Through Negation

By addressing that contemplating the mind is about the mind being neither self-generated nor other-generated, Chih-i demonstrates how truth can be realized through negation:

“In the case of empty space, if the mind that contemplates originates itself, then the mind does not need to rely on causes and conditions. Since the mind relies on causes and conditions, the mind has no power of self-generation. Since the mind has no power of self-generation, conditions cannot generate either. Since the mind and its condition have no [independent] existence, how can they be jointly substantial? If they cannot be obtained in conjunction, they cannot originate at all when they are in separation. If there is not even one single self-generation possible, how could there exist a hundred realms and a thousand dharmas? Because the mind is empty, everything that is created by the mind is empty. This emptiness is also empty. Such emptiness is not empty. Applying this Emptiness to the case of the Provisional, the Provisional is not provisional either. If there is neither Provisional nor Emptiness, it is ultimately pure and tranquil [the middle way].”

This passage stresses the significance of the mind contemplation. The method of contemplating the mind through negation is described as a way to realize the Middle Way-Ultimate Truth. By negating the mind that arises by its own or by another, one realizes the truth of Emptiness. By negating the substantiality of Emptiness and the Provisional, this prevents one from being attached to either of them, through which the truth as the Middle Way is realized. (Vol. 2, Page 82)

The Profound Meaning of the Lotus Sutra: Tien-tai Philosophy of Buddhism


Day 8

Day 8 concludes Chapter 4, Understanding by Faith, and closes the second volume of the Sutra of the Lotus Flower of the Wonderful Dharma.

Day 8 Full Text

Having last time heard the explanation of the parable, we repeat in gāthās.

Thereupon Mahā-Kāśyapa, wishing to repeat what they had said, sang in gāthās the start of the Parable of the Rich Man and His Poor Son:

Hearing your teaching of today,
We are dancing with joy.
We have never had
Such joy before.

You say:
“The Śrāvakas will be able to become Buddhas.”
We have obtained unsurpassed treasures
Although we did not seek them.

Suppose there lived a boy.
He was young and ignorant.
He ran away from his father
And went to a remote country.
He wandered from country to country
For more than fifty years.

The father anxiously sought him
In all directions.
Finally tiring of looking for him,
He settled in a certain city.

He built a house,
And enjoyed satisfaction
Of the five desires.
He was very rich.
He had a great deal of gold, silver,
Shell, agate, pearl and lapis lazuli;
And many elephants, horses,
Cows, sheep,
Palanquins, carts,
Farmers and attendants.
He invested his money in all the other countries,
And earned interest.
Merchants and customers
Were seen everywhere [around him].

Thousands of billions of people
Surrounded him respectfully.
He was favored by the king,
And respected
By the ministers,
And by the powerful families.

Many people came to see him
For various purposes. Because he was rich,
He was very powerful.
As he became older,
He thought more of his son.
He thought from morning till night:
“I shall die before long.
It is more than fifty years
Since my ignorant son left me
What shall I do
With the things in the store-houses?”

At that time the poor son
Wandered from village to village,
From country to country,
Seeking food and clothing.
Sometimes he got what he wanted,
At other times he could not.
Getting thinner from hunger,
He had scabs and itches on his skin.
Wandering from one place to another,
He came to the city of his father.
Employed at places from day to day,
He came to the house of his father.

At that time the rich man was sitting
On the lion-like seat
Under the great awning of treasures
Inside the gate of the house.
Many attendants were surrounding him.
Many people were on his guard.

Some of his attendants were counting
Gold, silver, and other treasures.
Some were keeping accounts;
Others, writing notes and bills.

Seeing his father noble and honorable,
The poor son thought:
“Is he a king,
Or someone like a king?”

Frightened and scared,
He wondered:
“Why did I come here?”
He thought:
“If I stay here any longer,
I shall be forced to work.”

Having thought this, he ran away.
He asked someone
For the way to a village of the poor
In order to get a job.

The Introduction to the Lotus Sutra offers this:

The narrative … told by the four sravakas is called the “Parable of the Rich Man and His Poor Son.” As we can see from what they have said, the Lesser Vehicle which they had been following stressed escape from this world of sorrows into a pure world of contemplation. Its concept of enlightenment was also passive. It concluded that “nothing is different from anything else,” and “there is nothing more to seek.” This view rejected the reality of this world and the necessity of working to change it. The Great Vehicle, on the other hand, interpreted the same doctrine [that nothing is substantial] positively as becoming a buddha in this world and transforming it into a buddha-world. Enlightenment is to be achieved within the turmoil of our daily life, not in silent seclusion. The four “hearers” now realize that they, too, have obtained the wonderful law of the Great Vehicle and have departed from the passivity of the Lesser Vehicle.

Introduction to the Lotus Sutra

Daily Dharma – Nov. 16, 2018

Ajita! Any good man or woman who keeps, reads, or recites this sūtra after my extinction, also will be able to obtain these merits. Know this! He or she should be considered to have already reached the place of enlightenment, approached Anuttara-samyak-saṃbodhi, and sat under the tree of enlightenment. Ajita! Erect a stūpa in the place where he or she sat, stood or walked! All gods and men should make offerings to that stūpa just as they do to the stūpa of a Buddha.

The Buddha gives this explanation to Maitreya (whom he calls Ajita – Invincible) in Chapter Seventeen of the Lotus Sūtra. In this mysterious description, the Buddha seems to say that anyone who practices this Lotus Sūtra as it instructs is his equal, that this person deserves as much respect as the Buddha himself. In this world of conflict it is rare to even find this teaching, and even more rare to practice it. The Buddha encourages Bodhisattvas such as Maitreya and other protective deities to serve and care for those who bring the Buddha’s greatest wisdom to life. When we practice the Wonderful Dharma, it is as if the Buddha himself appears among us.

The Daily Dharma is produced by the Lexington Nichiren Buddhist Community. To subscribe to the daily emails, visit zenzaizenzai.com

Mind Contemplation

The all-embracing feature of the mind contemplation is revealed by the unity of the three categories of Dharma in the quotation from the Avatamsakasūtra:

“The mind, Buddha, and sentient beings are of no distinction.”

Chih-i points out that what mind contemplation can achieve is described by yet another quote from the Avatamsakasūtra:

“When one’s mind traverses the Dharma-realm, taking it as if it is empty space, then one will know the objective realm of all Buddhas.”

Chih-i believes that this quotation, in terms of the mind traversing the Dharma-realm, suggests that mind is related to the Threefold Truth, and that contemplating the mind is the means to attain the Threefold Truth. Chih-i explains:

“The Dharma-realm is identical to the Middle Way. Empty space is identical to Emptiness. The mind and Buddhas are identical to the Provisional. The three together are identical to the objective realm of all Buddhas. This means that if one contemplates [the thought of] one’s mind, one can still be endowed with all the Buddha-dharmas.”

The all-embracing feature of the mind is further emphasized by Chih-i as he holds that contemplating the mind is about one thought embracing reality as a whole:

“In the case of one’s mind traversing the Dharma-realm, when contemplating the mutual opposition of a sensation and its object, one thought arises in the mind which must belong to one of the ten realms. When [one thought] belongs to one realm, it at once embraces one hundred realms and one thousand dharmas. The one thought is replete with all [aspects of reality].”

This passage addresses that all characteristics of reality are contained in the rising of one thought. Therefore, contemplating the mind is the most practical method in reaching truth. (Vol. 2, Page 81-82)

The Profound Meaning of the Lotus Sutra: Tien-tai Philosophy of Buddhism


Day 7

Day 7 concludes Chapter 3, A Parable, and begins Chapter 4, Understanding by Faith.

Day 7 Full Text

Having last time learned the greatness of the vehicle revealed in the Parable of the Burning House, we consider why the expedient message was necessary.

(The Buddha said to Śāriputra:)
All of you
All Are of my you children.
I am your father.

You were under the fires of many sufferings
For the past innumerable kalpas.
Therefore, I saved you
From the triple world [ with expedients].

I once told you that you had attained extinction.
But you eliminated only birth and death
[By that extinction].
The extinction you attained was not the true one.
What you should do now is
Obtain the wisdom of the Buddha.

The Bodhisattvas in this multitude
Should hear
With one mind
The true teaching of the Buddhas.

The Buddhas, the World-Honored Ones,
Say only expediently [that some are not Bodhisattvas]
To tell the truth,
All living beings taught by them are Bodhisattvas.

[I said:]
“To those who have little wisdom,
And who are deeply attached to sensual desires,
The Buddhas expound the truth that all is suffering.
Those [who hear this truth]
Will have the greatest joy that they have ever had.
The statement of the Buddhas that all is suffering
Is true, not false.
To those who are ignorant
Of the cause of all sufferings,
And who are too deeply attached
To the cause of suffering
To give it up even for a moment,
The Buddhas expound
The [eight right] ways as expedients.

The cause of suffering is greed.
When greed is eliminated,
There is nothing to be attached to.
The extinction of suffering
Is called the third truth.
In order to attain this extinction,
The [eight right] ways must be practiced.
Freedom from the bonds of suffering[,]
[That is, from illusions] is called emancipation.”

From what illusions can one be emancipated, however,
[By the practice of the eight right ways]?
He can be emancipated only from unreal things
[That is, from the five desires] thereby.
He cannot be emancipated from all illusions.
The Buddhas say
That he has not yet attained
The true extinction
Because he has not yet attained
Unsurpassed enlightenment.
I also do not think that I have led him
To the [true] extinction thereby.

The Daily Dharma from Jan. 26, 2018, offers this:

The Buddhas, the World-Honored Ones,
Say only expediently [that some are not Bodhisattvas]
To tell the truth,
All living beings taught by them are Bodhisattvas.

This verse comes from Chapter Three of the Lotus Sūtra. In Chapter Two, the Buddha declared that he only teaches Bodhisattvas. If we believe that we are not Bodhisattvas, we could conclude that the Buddha does not teach us. Part of what the Buddha is explaining here is that we are all Bodhisattvas. The way to reach the Buddha’s enlightenment is by living as Bodhisattvas: beings whose every breath is intended to improve our world.

The Daily Dharma is produced by the Lexington Nichiren Buddhist Community. To subscribe to the daily emails, visit zenzaizenzai.com

The 10 Voice Hearers

“Voice-hearers” (Sanskrit, shravaka) refers to those monastic disciples who heard the voice of the Buddha in person. From the stand­point of Mahayana Buddhism, the voice-hearers are Hinayana disciples who listened and followed the teachings of the Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path. … Traditionally ten major disciples are listed. They are representative of the different qualities that were valued by Hinayana Buddhism:

  • Shariputra, foremost in wisdom
  • Mahakashyapa, foremost in ascetic practices
  • Ananda, foremost in hearing the sutras
  • Subhuti, foremost in understanding emptiness
  • Purna, foremost in expounding the Dharma
  • Maudgalyayana, foremost in supernatural powers
  • Katyayana, foremost in explaining the Dharma
  • Aniruddha, foremost in clairvoyance (the divine eye)
  • Upali, foremost in observing the precepts
  • Rahula, foremost in inconspicuous practice
Lotus World: An Illustrated Guide to the Gohonzon

Daily Dharma – Nov. 15, 2018

Please remember that the service to your lord itself is practicing the teaching of the Lotus Sutra. Interpreting the scriptural statement in the Lotus Sutra, Grand Master T’ien-t’ai, therefore, states in his Great Concentration and Insight: “All the activities and daily work of the people in the secular world do not contradict the truth preached by the Buddha.” Please contemplate the spirit of this scriptural statement again and again.

Nichiren wrote this passage in his Response to a Follower (Dannotsu Bō Gohenji). In our frustration with this world of conflict, we may think it best to remove ourselves from those who are increasing the delusions of others. In this letter, Nichiren reminds us that the relationships we have in our lives are important. Service to others does not necessarily mean giving them what they ask for. It means wishing that they lose their delusions and nourishing the Buddha nature within them.

The Daily Dharma is produced by the Lexington Nichiren Buddhist Community. To subscribe to the daily emails, visit zenzaizenzai.com

Mind Contemplation

For Chih-i, mind contemplation is the most accessible way to approach the Ultimate Truth, because Dharma of Sentient Beings is too broad and Dharma of Buddha is too high in approaching the Ultimate Truth. Contemplating mind, on the other hand, is related to the Threefold Truth and to the all-embracing feature of the mind. As the Ultimate Truth concerns the Threefold Truth and is all embracing, mind contemplation is proved to be the ultimate approach of penetrating the Ultimate Truth. (Vol. 2, Page 81)

The Profound Meaning of the Lotus Sutra: Tien-tai Philosophy of Buddhism


Day 6

Day 6 continues Chapter 3, A Parable

Day 6 Full Text

Having last time considered Śākyamuni’s skillful expedients, we consider who was attracted to the sheep cart, the deer cart and the bullock cart.

“Śāriputra! Those who have intelligence, who receive the Dharma by faith after hearing it from the Buddha, from the World Honored One, and who seek Nirvāṇa with strenuous efforts in order to get out of the triple world, are called Śrāvakas. They may be likened to the children who left the burning house in order to get the sheep-carts. Those who receive the Dharma by faith after hearing it from the Buddha, from the World-Honored One, who seek the self-originating wisdom with strenuous efforts, who wish to have good tranquility in seclusion, and who perfectly understand the causes of all things, are called Pratyekabuddhas. They may be likened to the children who left the burning house in order to get the deer-carts. Those who receive the Dharma by faith after hearing it from the Buddha, from the World-Honored One, who strenuously seek the knowledge of all things, the wisdom of the Buddha, the self-originating wisdom, the wisdom to be obtained without teachers, and the insight and powers and fearlessness of the Tathāgata, who give peace to innumerable living beings out of their compassion towards them, and who benefit gods and men, that is to say, who save all living beings, are called men of the Great Vehicle. Bodhisattvas are called Mahasattvas because they seek this vehicle. They may be likened to the children who left the burning house in order to get the bullock-carts.

The Introduction to the Lotus Sutra offers this on the Three Carts:

From the theoretical standpoint, [The Parable of the Burning House] explains the relationship between the Three Vehicles and the One Vehicle. The three toy carts – the sheep-cart, deer-cart, and bullock-cart – respectively represent the Sravaka-Vehicle of the “hearers,” the Pratyekabuddha-Vehicle of the “private Buddhas,” and the Bodhisattva-Vehicle of those who serve and enlighten others. The large white bullock cart which is given to each of the children symbolizes the One Buddha Vehicle. The rich man first offered his children three kinds of carts as expedients, but in the end he gave each of them an identical large white bullock-cart. Obviously the Buddha told this parable to illustrate that the One Vehicle is true and the three are mere expedients. The differences between the One Vehicle and the Three Vehicles, which were discussed theoretically in Chapter Two, are now explained in a graphic story that anyone can understand and remember.

Introduction to the Lotus Sutra

Karmic Inheritance

People understand that the nature of karma is that it is the result of our own previous wrongdoings which we made in a previous life (we just don’t remember), of the present life, and we must reap what we have sown by ourselves. However, if you cannot completely atone for the harvest of bad karma during your life, it will be transferred to your children or grandchildren just like an inheritance. This shows that our bad karma is not always only caused by us. Therefore, since olden times people have feared karma, prayed to the Buddha and examined their own behavior carefully.
It is especially important that we should know that by making good karma we are able to extinguish bad karma. Therefore, karma is not fatalism, but is an improvable problem.

Summer Writings