Category Archives: Peaceful Action

Peaceful Action, Open Heart: Lessons from the Lotus Sutra

peaceful-action-open-heart-bookcoverFrom Amazon:

Peaceful Action, Open Heart shines 60 years of study and practice upon one of the crowning scriptures of the path of the Buddha, and is destined to be known as one of the most significant writings by Thich Nhat Hanh.

The Lotus Sutra is one of the most revered of Mahayana sacred texts and is sometimes called “the king of sutras.” Despite this fact, there are very few commentaries in English available today. Thich Nhat Hanh explores the Sutra’s main theme – that everyone has the capacity to become a Buddha, and that Buddha-nature is inherent in everything – but he also uniquely emphasizes the sutra’s insight that Buddha-nature is the basis for peaceful action. Since we all will one day become a Buddha, he says, we can use mindfulness practices right now to understand and find solutions to current world challenges. In his interpretation of the sutra, he suggests that if the practices, views, and insights of the Lotus Sutra would find application not only by individuals but also by nations, it would offer concrete solutions to transform individual suffering and the global challenges facing the world today.

Stamped with his signature depth of vision, lucidity, and clarity, Thich Nhat Hanh’s insights based on the wisdom of the Lotus Sutra invoke a wide range of contemporary topics and concerns, such as the Palestinian-Israeli war, the threat of terrorism, and the degradation of our environment. In proposing radical new ways of finding peaceful solutions to universal, contemporary conflicts, he not only challenges the U.N to change from an organization to a real organism working for peace and harmony in the world, but also encourages all branches of all governments to act as Sangha. In so doing, he demonstrates the practical and direct applicability of this sacred text to today’s concerns.

This book has been re-released with a new title. The earlier hardcover edition was entitled Opening the Heart of the Cosmos.


One must assume that the publisher offered the third paragraph for purposes of expanding the potential reach of the book. While the environment is an important aspect of Thich Nhat Hanh’s teaching, the suggestion that the Palestinian-Israeli conflict and the United Nations are significant topics is unfounded, at least in the 2008 edition published under the title, Peaceful Action, Open Heart.”

I was introduced to this book in July, 2020, when Ryuei Shonin announced the creation of an Amazon Wish List for his Lotus Sutra Study program. This is the first book by Thich Nhat Hanh that I’ve read. And as with Nikkyō Niwano’s commentary on the Lotus Sutra, I feel a need to distance myself from some of the interpretations of Thich Nhat Hanh.

Here is an example from Thich Nhat Hanh’s discussion of the Buddha’s prediction for Shariputra in Chapter 3, A Parable:

Hearing this the Buddha said, “Shariputra, in past lives you studied and practiced with me, and I taught you the bodhisattva way. But in this lifetime you forgot it and, following the path of the shravaka, believed you had reached the final goal of your practice, nirvana. Now, through teaching this Lotus Blossom of the Fine Dharma, I am able to reestablish you on the bodhisattva path. In the future you will become the Buddha Flower Glow (Padmaprabha) in a Buddha Land called Free of Defilements (Viraja). You will do as I do, and teach the three vehicles to guide living beings, and finally you will also teach the One Vehicle, just as I am teaching now.”

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p46-47

Thich Nhat Hanh book’s endnotes indicate that he is using Leon Hurvitz’s translation of the Lotus Blossom of the Fine Dharma for his English language quotes, but in this instance Thich Nhat Hanh has not only grossly paraphrased but also fabricated new text.

Here’s the relevant portion from Hurvitz:

“Flower Glow, the Thus Come One, shall furthermore by resort to the three vehicles teach and convert the beings. Śāriputra, though the time of that buddha’s emergence shall not be an evil age, by reason of his former vow he shall preach the dharma of the three vehicles.”

Lotus Blossom of the Fine Dharma, p51

Few things in the Lotus Sutra are more puzzling to me than the prediction that Śāriputra will teach the Three Vehicles even though the kalpa in which he becomes that Buddha “will not be an evil age.” If only the Buddha, as Thich Nhat Hanh erroneously inserts, had added, “finally you will also teach the One Vehicle, just as I am teaching now.” But the Buddha doesn’t say Śāriputra will ever teach the One Vehicle or the Lotus Sutra.

Before I start posting quotes here from the book I’ll be posting several articles concerning problems of one sort or another that I have with Thich Nhat Hanh interpretation.

Having said that, I should underline my overall satisfaction and favorable opinion of “Peaceful Action, Open Heart: Lessons from the Lotus Sutra.”

I fully endorse this from the Introduction:

This book shows how the teachings of the Sutra can help us realize the practices of mindfulness, compassion, and love for the well-being of our family, our community, our society, and the world.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p8

And this beautiful poem by Thich Nhat Hanh:

Reciting the Lotus Sutra

At night as I recite the Lotus Sutra
The sound moves the galaxies
The Earth below wakes up
In her lap suddenly flowers appear

At night as I recite the Lotus Sutra
A jeweled Stupa appears resplendent.
All over the sky bodhisattvas are seen
And Buddha’s hand is in mine.

—Thich Nhat Hanh



Book Quotes

Book List

800 Years: The Fruit of Great Merit

The teaching of the Lotus Sutra on the ultimate dimension is a very great, joyful truth. From our limited perspective of reality we have etched in our minds the idea of birth and death, of coming and going, existence and nonexistence. We have gotten used to this view of reality. And now someone comes along and opens up the treasure of the ultimate for us, the priceless truth of no birth, no death, of infinite life span, essential Buddha nature, and imminent Buddhahood. Are we able to bear such a profound truth or not? When we hear the Buddha teach this truth – and we are able to practice it, bear it, accept it, and hold it in our hearts, smile and have faith in it – then we will enjoy the fruit of great merit.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p123

800 Years: Acceptance in Faith

There is nothing we teach that is not the truth, and the value of what we teach is equivalent to that of the Dharma taught by all the Buddhas in the sutras. The far-reaching merit of the Lotus Sutra transforms all those who hear it, understand it, accept it in faith, and practice it into teachers of Dharma who share their insight and joy with others in order to help them realize the truth of the ultimate dimension and cross to the shore of freedom.
Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p126

800 Years: The Buddha’s Faith in Us

The Buddha shows great faith in us by entrusting the wonderful Dharma to us. We can repay this trust and faith by becoming the arms and hands of the Buddha and continuing the Tathagata’s great work of leading all beings to the shore of liberation.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p136

800 Years: The Requirement of Faith

Chapter 23 of the Lotus Sutra, “The Former Affairs of the Bodhisattva Medicine King,” introduces us to another great bodhisattva, Bhaisajyaraja, Medicine King. Bhaisaiya means medicine, raja means king. Just like Sadaparibhuta, this bodhisattva is also a model of enlightened action. Medicine King realizes the teachings of the Lotus Sutra in another sphere of action, the sphere of devotion, faith, and gratitude. Without faith it is not possible for human beings to live. Without love we cannot truly realize our full humanity. We practice the Dharma not only to gain knowledge but to transform ourselves into someone who is capable of love, affection, and gratitude. Medicine King represents this aspect. The bodhisattvas in the Lotus Sutra are the arms and hands of the Buddha, carrying out the various actions of the Buddha. Just as Bodhisattva Sadaparibhuta has a specific role to play, Medicine King Bodhisattva has another role to play.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p154

800 Years: A Feeling of Faith

Then the Buddha says to Bodhisattva Maitreya, “If a good man or woman should hear me teach about the infinite life span of the Tathagata and give rise to a feeling of faith and understanding, that person is already sitting in the great assembly on Mount Gṛdhrakūṭa at this very moment.” This is the merit of receiving and practicing the Lotus Sutra. If you are able to hear this wonderful Dharma from a friend or teacher, from a bird singing or the sound of a flowing stream, if you read or hear the Sutra, understand and have faith in it, get in touch with the ultimate dimension of the Tathagata and of everything in the universe, then right in that moment you are sitting alongside the Buddha. You do not have to go back 2,600 years to be able to see and touch the Buddha. You are able to realize that profound happiness right away, in this very moment.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p123-124

800 Years: Accepting in Faith

There is nothing we teach that is not the truth, and the value of what we teach is equivalent to that of the Dharma taught by all the Buddhas in the sutras. The far-reaching merit of the Lotus Sutra transforms all those who hear it, understand it, accept it in faith, and practice it into teachers of Dharma who share their insight and joy with others in order to help them realize the truth of the ultimate dimension and cross to the shore of freedom.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p126

The Story of Aṅgulimāla

Aṅgulimāla [was] a murderer in the time of the Buddha. His name means “garland of fingers,” because he wore a necklace strung with the fingers of his victims. So you can see that there was a lot of anger and hatred in Aṅgulimāla. He was a hungry ghost; he believed that no one loved him, that human beings were by nature cruel, dishonest, and unfaithful, and he became a thief and a murderer.

One day the Buddha went on the almsround in the city of Shravasti, and found all the houses locked. Everyone was afraid because Aṅgulimāla was in the area. One person asked the Buddha to come into his house to receive food there and not wander around outside because it was too dangerous. But the Buddha said, “It is my practice to do walking meditation and visit many homes and meet with people. I cannot just stay in one house,” and he continued on his almsround.

As he was walking through the forest on his way back to the monastery, the Buddha suddenly heard the sound of someone running behind him, and a voice called out, “Monk, hey monk, stop!” The Buddha knew that it was Aṅgulimāla, but he simply continued to practice walking meditation with peace and solidity. He didn’t feel afraid because he had a lot of calmness and compassion within himself. Soon Aṅgulimāla caught up with him and, falling into step next to him, said, “Monk, I told you to stop. Why didn’t you stop?” The Buddha continued walking mindfully and said quietly, “Aṅgulimāla, I have already stopped a long time ago. It is you who have not stopped.”

Aṅgulimāla was quite surprised by this. No one had ever spoken to him in this way; everyone had always trembled in fear of him. He ran in front of the Buddha to force him to stop walking and said, “What do you mean by that? I told you to stop but you are still walking. You haven’t stopped, but you say that you have already stopped. Explain this to me.”

The Buddha looked at Aṅgulimāla and said very calmly, “Aṅgulimāla, I stopped doing cruel and harmful things a long time ago. I don’t want to create suffering and despair, and that is why I have learned the path of compassion and understanding. No living being wants to suffer, no living being wants to die, everyone wants to live and be happy. We should be aware of that. We should try to be compassionate and respect life and be kind to other beings. We should love others, instead of hating them and killing them.”

Aṅgulimāla shouted, “Human beings are very cruel. No one loves me, no one understands me. Why should I be compassionate toward them?”

The Buddha replied, “Aṅgulimāla, I agree with you that there are very cruel human beings, and they have made you suffer. But I don’t agree with you that all human beings are like that. There are many people who are very compassionate and kind. Have you ever met one of my monks or nuns? There are many of them in the town. They practice loving kindness and compassion. They don’t want to harm even a tiny insect. You know, when we have compassion within us, we suffer much less.”

Aṅgulimāla was very surprised and curious. He thought, “This monk knows that I am Aṅgulimāla, yet he’s not afraid of me. Maybe he is the one called Gautama I have heard of.” So he asked the Buddha, “Are you Gautama, the Buddha?”

“Yes.”

“Buddha, it’s too late to do what you suggest.”

“It’s never too late to do a good thing,” said the Buddha.

“What good thing can I do?” asked Aṅgulimāla.

The Buddha said, “To stop wrongdoing, to stop creating suffering for yourself and others is the greatest good that you can do.”

“It’s too late for me. I have committed so many crimes. Even if
I wanted to stop now, people wouldn’t leave me in peace.”

“Aṅgulimāla, if you really want to turn away from violence and follow the path of compassion and kindness, I promise to help you.”

Aṅgulimāla was so moved by the Buddha’s kindness and nonfear, at that very moment he threw down his sword, knelt down, and asked to become his disciple. Right then Śāriputra and some of the other monks arrived, They had been out looking for the Buddha because they knew that Aṅgulimāla was around. Now they found the Buddha safe with the notorious criminal, who already had taken refuge. They were all very glad. The Buddha instructed Śāriputra to cut Aṅgulimāla’s hair right then and there, give him a robe to wear, and take him back to the monastery to begin training in the practice. He told Śāriputra to keep him in the monastery for several weeks, so he wouldn’t have to go into the city on the almsround every day like the other monks. Aṅgulimāla devoted all his time to learning the practice of mindfulness, and in no time at all he became a very good monk. His transformation took place very quickly because he wanted with all his being to completely change his life.

After a month or so, the Buddha allowed Aṅgulimāla to accompany him on almsround in the city, On the way, the Buddha saw King Prasenajit speaking to a group of soldiers. The Buddha greeted the king and asked, “Majesty, are you preparing the army for a war? Is there some trouble at the frontier?”

King Prasenajit said, “No, Lord, there is no war at the frontier.”

“Why are you gathering an army?” asked the Buddha.

“Because I have heard that Aṅgulimāla is in town. He’s a very dangerous person. One time I sent fifty soldiers into a forest after him, and he killed most of them. So I am personally directing a military operation to capture this dangerous killer.”

While the Buddha was talking to the king, Aṅgulimāla was standing directly behind him and could hear everything that was being said. The Buddha asked Prasenajit, “If Aṅgulimāla wished to repent all his mistakes, take vows to renounce killing, and practice loving kindness and compassion as a monk, would you still want to capture and kill him?”

The king said, “In that case, my Lord, I would not arrest him. If he really can do that, if he can become a gentle monk and practice the mindfulness trainings, then I vow not to arrest and execute him. Instead I will offer him clothing, food, a bed, and medicine.” These were the four requisites of a monk in the Buddha’s time, given as offerings to monastics by laypeople.

After the king spoke, the Buddha stepped aside and pointed to the monk behind him, “Here is Aṅgulimāla.”

At first the king was startled and afraid, but through practicing mindful breathing he recognized that he was safe with the Buddha. He turned to Aṅgulimāla and asked him, “Bhikshu, what is your name? Where do you come from?”

After Aṅgulimāla answered King Prasenajit’s questions in a very gentle voice, the king was convinced. He said, “I am ready and eager to offer you the four requisites.”

Aṅgulimāla replied, “Majesty, I have everything I need, thank you very much for your concern.” He spoke in a very gentle and kind way.

Then the king turned to the Buddha and exclaimed, “Wonderful, Lord, wonderful! What you have done, no one of us could do, not even an army could do. Your non-fear, gentleness, and compassion have won over Aṅgulimāla. You have done the most difficult thing. Your power of transformation and healing is very great. Beloved teacher, I thank you for what you have done to keep peace in the city and in this country.”

When he became a monk, Aṅgulimāla received the new Dharma name Ahimsa (nonviolence). This shows that it is possible even for someone who has committed very serious crimes and fallen far into the realm of hell to completely transform.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p209-213

The Wings of a Bird

The Prajn͂āpāramitā Sutra describes the perfection of wisdom, prajn͂ā paramita, as “the wings of a bird that can carry you very far.” It is the foundation and the key to the realization of all the paramitas. With this kind of understanding we can practice giving, mindfulness, inclusiveness, diligence, and meditation perfectly. Without prajn͂ā paramita the perfection of the other paramitas is impossible – without wings you cannot go far.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p269

The Practice of Calming, Concentrating, and Looking Deeply

Dhyana, meditation, is the practice of calming, concentrating, and looking deeply. Meditation should be understood first of all as the cultivation of samadhi, meditative awareness. Then when we take teachings such as the Three Dharma Seals – impermanence, non-self, and nirvana – as the object of our concentration, they become real insights into our lived experience, not just ideas or concepts.

The core Buddhist teaching of impermanence tells us that all things arise and pass away according to their causes and conditions. Nothing lasts forever; nothing is a permanent, unchanging thing unto itself. Many practitioners think that they understand the teaching of impermanence perfectly, but they do not really believe in it. We have a strong tendency to believe that we will remain the same person forever and that our loved ones will also remain the same forever, but this is a kind of delusion that prevents us from living in a more mindful and compassionate way. If we believe that everyone and everything we love will always be there, we have little concern to take care of them, to treasure them deeply right here and now. When we lose something or someone we love, we suffer. Yet when that thing or person was still present in our lives we may not have treasured it, we didn’t fully appreciate him or her, because we lacked the insight of impermanence. It’s very important to make the insight of impermanence the object of our meditative awareness, because this insight is an essential element of love and compassion.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p265-266

The Quality of Diligence

The next paramita, vīrya, is very often misinterpreted. Bringing the quality of diligence to our practice does not mean that we have to drive ourselves very hard and suffer a lot. Many people think that to be a diligent practitioner you have to practice sitting meditation for one or two hours, or you have to sit all day until you feel pain all through your body, and you think that this is good. You are able to push yourself hard, and so you feel like a hero. You can bear the pain in your mind and body. You have made it. You have survived a retreat.

This is not the practice of vīrya. You don’t have to suffer in order to progress in the practice. True diligence, wholesome energy, and effort in our practice, is born from joy. The point of the practice is not to create more suffering, but to bring well-being, transformation, and healing. We are not practicing only to achieve some better state in the future, but in order to get in touch with the joy and peace that are available right now, in every moment. If you practice with the correct attitude, you will feel relief from suffering right away.

Peaceful Action, Open Heart, p260